Skip to main content

Community blog

Roedy Green

Why Carbon Tax?

By Roedy Green - 21 months ago

I heard Gerard Kennedy of the Liberals say that Dr. Suzuki favoured a carbon tax over cap and trade.

I wonder what the advantages of carbon tax are to make him prefer that option.

The key factor that has me at this point supporting cap and trade in that a carbon tax would not actually reduce CO2 until the tax reached $200 a tonne (or whatever level that make cleaning up more economic that polluting).  It seems to me most companies will just pay the tax rather that clean up.  The idea is to gradually increase the tax.  It seems to be just an excuse to do nothing.  Once the level gets high enough it would suddenly kick in and clean things up a a heck of a hurry.  I worry that politicians would always keep that level below the level needed to have any effect.  Politicians LOVE to look as they are doing something without actually doing anything.

In contrast, cap and trade forces a reduction in year one.

Article Rating

Average: No Rating Available (0 votes)  

1 Comment

 
Cornell Van Ryk Cornell Van Ryk - 21 months ago

Cap and trade = reduction....maybe!!!  I just watched a program where they were selling carbon credits for saving Indonesian rain forest. In my mind, keeping a tree in existance does nothing to compensate for someone else putting more CO2 into the atmosphere.A good idea to save the rain forest, yes, but does nothing to reduce CO2.


Would you like to comment?

You must be a member. Sign In if you are already a member.


Viewed 1093 times